Is light rail the answer to all urban transportation problems?
No.
Is light rail an essential component in addressing urban transportation problems?
Absolutely!
The key word is "component." I was a real skeptic about the value of rail
transit when I was appointed in 1993 to the regional board of elected
officials that was tackling transit issues in the greater Puget Sound
region. Reports of light rail's high capital costs and history of not
achieving its projected ridership caused me to question seriously whether
it would be cost effective.
However, the more I delved into transit issues and transportation in
general the more I became convinced that a transportation system has to be
viewed as just that, a system.
Transportation systems are textbook examples of the whole being greater
than the sum of its parts. To single out one component for analysis
completely misses the point. No one component – light rail, buses,
commuter rail, van and car pools, taxi cabs, private vehicles, walking or
bicycles – by itself provide the "silver bullet" solution that everyone
seems to be looking for to address our region's transportation problems.
However, put all together as a system they can achieve goals of personal
mobility, growth, economic development, air quality and overall quality of
life.